top of page

Pagan Weekly Round Up | October 10th - 24th

Writer: Tish Owen
Tish Owen
Oct 25
34 min read


Religious Liberty Under Pressure


The Ottumwa Invocation Controversy

Following the national spotlight on Iowa, local civil rights watchdogs in Florida highlighted an ongoing dispute over opening prayers in Pensacola, Florida. Christian nationalist groups are actively pressuring the city council to scrap its open, rotating invocation policy entirely rather than risk allowing non-traditional or minority religious viewpoints to take the microphone.


What began as an effort to make space for different perspectives at an Iowa city council meeting has sparked a much larger conversation about religious freedom, government neutrality, and whose beliefs are welcome in public spaces.


On October 6, Matt Dalbey, a former Ottumwa City Council member and member of the Satanic Temple of Iowa, delivered a scheduled invocation before the council’s official proceedings. The opportunity was part of a policy adopted in January 2026 that allows local residents to volunteer to lead invocations representing a variety of religious and nonreligious perspectives.


Dalbey’s invocation emphasized reason, knowledge, truth, personal autonomy, and freedom from arbitrary authority. He concluded with “Hail Satan,” prompting a strong reaction from some people in attendance.


Mayor Benjamin Foote subsequently called for a moment of silence, initially describing it as an opportunity to reverse what he characterized as a curse on the city. Councilwoman Cara Galloway objected to interrupting the proceedings, arguing that opening meetings to different viewpoints means accepting that some speakers will express beliefs others may not share.


Galloway later reiterated her concerns, explaining that allowing invocations also means allowing perspectives that may be unpopular or uncomfortable to some members of the community.


The incident raised questions about how consistently Ottumwa’s policy of religious inclusion would be applied when a speaker’s beliefs differ from those of local officials or other attendees.


For more on this check out our article here


FFRF Weighs In

Now, the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) is calling on Ottumwa to discontinue religious invocations at city council meetings altogether.


In a letter to Mayor Foote and the City Council, the national organization argues that the incident illustrates the problems that can arise when religious practices become part of official government proceedings. FFRF specifically criticizes the decision to accommodate a pastor’s demand for a religious response after Dalbey’s invocation, arguing that officials cannot invite people from diverse religious and nonreligious backgrounds to participate and then effectively allow one perspective to override another.


The organization also pushed back against the mayor’s suggestion that Dalbey’s invocation did not represent the community’s faith or values. According to FFRF, no mayor can speak for every resident’s beliefs or determine that minority religious and nonreligious perspectives fall outside the community.


FFRF further clarified that the Satanic Temple is a nontheistic religious organization. Its members do not believe in a literal Satan, and the organization says Dalbey’s invocation expressed philosophical principles rather than an attempt to curse the city.


What Is FFRF Asking the City to Do?

FFRF is asking the Ottumwa City Council to end invocations entirely and focus on the secular responsibilities of local government. The organization has also requested a written response explaining what steps the council intends to take to address the incident and prevent similar discriminatory treatment in the future.


The issue is not simply whether a particular invocation was offensive to some listeners. It is whether a government body can provide an equal opportunity for religious expression without favoring certain beliefs over others.


Ottumwa’s existing policy calls for speakers to be selected without preference for a particular religion, faith, belief, or ideology. However, it also includes language about inviting a creator into government decision-making, raising additional questions about whether the policy presumes a shared religious outlook.


For FFRF, the controversy reinforces its position that government meetings should not begin with religious rituals. Rather than attempting to manage competing religious responses, the organization argues that the city should remove the practice altogether.


The Bigger Picture

This controversy highlights a difficult question facing communities across the country: What does religious neutrality look like when people hold deeply different beliefs?


Allowing diverse perspectives to be heard requires more than opening the door to minority faiths. It also means applying the same standards when those perspectives challenge the expectations of the majority.


As the conversation continues in Ottumwa, the future of the city’s invocation policy remains an important part of the story. FFRF has made its request, but the council’s next steps will determine whether the policy changes or invocations continue under the existing rules.



From Controversy to Policy: How Pensacola Navigated a Decade of Disputes Over City Council Invocations

In the summer of 2016, a city council invocation in Pensacola, Florida, became the center of a heated debate over religious freedom, public prayer, and the role of government in accommodating different beliefs.


Nearly a decade later, the city's response offers a case study in how local governments attempt to balance religious expression with the constitutional principle that government should not favor one faith over another.


The controversy began when David Suhor, representing the Satanic Temple of West Florida, was scheduled to deliver an invocation before the Pensacola City Council. His appearance prompted a strong reaction from some people in attendance, several of whom recited Christian prayers while he spoke.


The incident drew national attention and raised a question that continues to surface in communities across the country: What happens when a government body that welcomes prayer encounters a religious or nonreligious viewpoint that some members of the public find objectionable?


The 2016 Controversy

Before Suhor's scheduled appearance on July 14, 2016, city officials considered whether to replace the invocation with a moment of silence. Ultimately, the council allowed him to speak.

During the invocation, audience members interrupted with Christian prayers. Council President Charles Bare attempted to restore order and warned that the chamber could be cleared if the interruptions continued.


The incident became a flashpoint in a broader national debate about legislative prayer and religious inclusion. While some residents viewed the invocation as an unwelcome challenge to their religious beliefs, others argued that allowing a speaker to participate was part of treating different viewpoints equally.


The controversy also demonstrated the practical difficulty of maintaining an invocation tradition in a religiously diverse community. A policy that accommodates familiar religious practices may face a different test when someone representing a minority faith or a nontraditional religious organization requests the same opportunity.


Public discussion continued in the following weeks. At an August 2016 council meeting, Suhor and other speakers addressed the controversy, keeping the question of invocations in the public conversation.


February 2017: Pensacola Establishes a Formal Policy

Rather than permanently discontinue invocations following the controversy, Pensacola moved toward a formal policy governing the practice.


On February 9, 2017, the City Council adopted Resolution 17-14, establishing rules addressing opening invocations and the Pledge of Allegiance.


The policy emphasized non-exclusion in the selection of volunteer speakers, diversity of viewpoints, and the non-exclusion of attendees. The resolution passed by a 6–0 vote among the council members present.


The adoption of a written policy was a significant development. Instead of leaving the issue solely to informal decisions made in the aftermath of a contentious meeting, the city established a framework intended to address how invocations would be handled.


However, adopting a policy and applying it consistently are two different things. The existence of written rules does not, on its own, establish whether every eligible speaker has received equal consideration or whether the policy has been administered without discrimination.

Those questions depend on how the rules operate in practice.


The City's Disclaimer: Separating Private Expression From Government Endorsement

In subsequent years, Pensacola's council agendas continued to include a disclaimer explaining the city's position on invocations.


Meeting materials from 2021 and 2022 described the invocation as a voluntary offering by a private individual. The language stated that the speaker's views had not been reviewed or approved by city officials, that the city did not endorse the speaker's religious or nonreligious beliefs, and that attendees were not required to participate.


Similar language appeared in council agendas from April 2023 and August 2024, as well as a February 2026 meeting document.


The disclaimer reflects an effort to distinguish an individual's expression from the official position of the city government. It also communicates that participation is voluntary rather than a requirement imposed on residents attending a public meeting.


But a disclaimer cannot answer every constitutional question surrounding legislative prayer. The selection process, the nature of the government's involvement, and the treatment of speakers representing different beliefs remain relevant.


In other words, saying that a government does not endorse a speaker's views is not the same as demonstrating that its invitation process is fair.



The Legal Framework: What the Supreme Court Has Said

Pensacola's experience sits within a larger body of constitutional law governing legislative prayer.


In its 2014 decision in Town of Greece v. Galloway, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a town's practice of opening legislative meetings with prayer. The decision recognized a longstanding tradition of legislative prayer while emphasizing that government bodies cannot use the practice to promote one faith, disparage other beliefs, or discriminate against religious minorities.


The ruling did not require local governments to maintain invocations. Nor did it establish that every person who requests an opportunity to speak must automatically receive one. Instead, the constitutionality of a particular practice depends on its circumstances, including how speakers are selected and how the government treats different viewpoints.


For municipalities, this creates a difficult policy question. Continuing invocations means navigating a practice that can involve deeply held religious beliefs, public expectations, and constitutional limits. Ending invocations is also an option for governments that prefer to avoid incorporating prayer into official proceedings.


Pensacola's decision to formalize its approach in 2017 illustrates one attempt to manage those competing concerns without eliminating the tradition altogether.


What Changed Between 2017 and 2026?

Available city records show that Pensacola continued using language distinguishing private invocations from government endorsement for years after the original controversy.


The city also amended its broader Rules and Procedures in May 2022. However, the available legislative record does not establish that those amendments specifically changed the invocation policy.


Likewise, the presence of invocation disclaimers in meeting materials through February 2026 demonstrates continuity in the city's stated approach, but it does not independently establish that every element of the speaker-selection process remained unchanged throughout the entire period.


A complete assessment would require comparing the original text of Resolution 17-14 with the latest applicable rules, along with reviewing records showing how speakers were selected and whether requests were denied.


That distinction is important when evaluating claims about religious inclusion. Written policies show what a government says it intends to do. Meeting records and documented decisions help establish how that policy operates in practice.


A Decade-Long Question About Religious Neutrality

Pensacola's experience demonstrates that disputes over legislative prayer do not necessarily end when a city adopts a formal policy. The underlying questions remain: Who gets to speak? What happens when a speaker's beliefs differ from those of the majority? And how can a government maintain neutrality while allowing religious expression in an official setting?


The city's response to the 2016 controversy was to establish a written invocation policy rather than immediately eliminate the practice. Subsequent meeting agendas continued to distinguish speakers' personal beliefs from the city's official position.


Whether those safeguards have been consistently applied is a separate question that requires examining the policy alongside the city's actual decisions.


For communities navigating similar debates, Pensacola offers an important example of the challenges involved in balancing religious expression, public participation, and government neutrality.


The broader issue extends beyond any single invocation: religious freedom includes the ability to hold beliefs that differ from those of one's neighbors. For a government committed to neutrality, the challenge is ensuring that its policies account for that diversity rather than simply reflecting the expectations of the majority.


The biggest update is that the land transfer has now been completed, so the story has moved beyond whether Oak Flat will be transferred. The fight is now also about whether the transfer and planned mine can still be stopped through remaining legal challenges. The U.S. Forest Service signed its environmental record of decision on March 16, 2026, and the Associated Press later reported that the federal land had been conveyed to Resolution Copper after an appeals court lifted an injunction.



Apache Stronghold v. United States: Full Context and Timeline


The case of Apache Stronghold v. United States is a major religious-freedom and Indigenous rights dispute involving a sacred Apache site in Arizona, a federally authorized copper mine, and the legal limits of protecting religious practices tied to specific land.


As of October 2026, the situation has changed significantly: the federal land transfer has been completed, but litigation challenging the transfer and the environmental review is continuing. The Supreme Court declined to hear Apache Stronghold's original appeal in 2025, and the Ninth Circuit declined to reconsider a separate land-transfer ruling in September 2026.


1. What is Oak Flat, and why does it matter?

Oak Flat, or Chí’chil Biłdagoteel

Located in Arizona's Tonto National Forest, Oak Flat is sacred to Western Apache people, including members of the San Carlos Apache Tribe. The site is used for prayer, religious ceremonies, and gathering medicinal plants. Its spiritual significance is tied to the land itself, not simply to a building or a location that can be replaced elsewhere.


One of the ceremonies associated with Oak Flat is the Sunrise Ceremony, a multiday coming-of-age ceremony for young Apache women. The ceremony involves specific plants and materials from the site, as well as prayers and ceremonial practices rooted in Apache spiritual traditions.

Western Apache religious beliefs also associate Oak Flat with the Ga'an, spiritual beings central to their religious traditions. For practitioners, the land is an integral part of the relationship between their community, their Creator, and their spiritual practices.


This is the core of the religious-freedom argument: if a sacred landscape is destroyed, worshippers cannot necessarily continue the same religious practice at another location.


How the mining project became possible

The conflict has roots extending back decades.

  • 1995: A major copper deposit was identified beneath Oak Flat, increasing commercial interest in mining the area.

  • December 2014: Congress included a land-exchange provision in the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2015. The provision directed the federal government to exchange approximately 2,422 acres of federal land, including Oak Flat, for approximately 5,344 acres of land owned by Resolution Copper.

  • The intended outcome: Resolution Copper, a venture involving mining companies Rio Tinto and BHP, would gain access to the copper deposit beneath the site.

  • Environmental review: The law required an environmental impact statement before the exchange could proceed.


Opponents argue that the proposed block-cave mine would cause the ground above the deposit to collapse, ultimately creating a crater roughly two miles wide and about 1,000 feet deep. They contend that this would permanently destroy Oak Flat's ability to serve as a sacred place of worship.


Supporters of the mine, including federal officials and Resolution Copper, point to domestic copper production, national security, energy infrastructure, employment, and economic benefits. The company has estimated that the project could generate substantial economic activity and thousands of jobs.


Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA)

RFRA generally prohibits the federal government from substantially burdening a person's religious exercise unless it can satisfy a demanding legal test involving a compelling governmental interest and the least restrictive means of achieving that interest.

Apache Stronghold argues that transferring Oak Flat for a mine would effectively eliminate religious practices that can only take place at that location.


First Amendment: Free Exercise Clause

The coalition also argued that the transfer violated the constitutional protection for the free exercise of religion. The courts rejected its claims at the preliminary-injunction stage under the applicable legal standards.


The 1852 Treaty of Santa Fe

Apache Stronghold also invoked an 1852 treaty, arguing that it created obligations for the federal government to protect traditional uses of ancestral lands. The Ninth Circuit rejected the coalition's treaty claim in the litigation before it.


The central legal dispute is not whether Oak Flat has religious significance. The litigation has focused on whether the federal government's transfer of its own land constitutes a legally cognizable, or “substantial,” burden on religious exercise under the statutes and precedents the courts applied.

That distinction has profound implications for Indigenous religious traditions, particularly those in which a specific landscape is essential to worship.


The major court decisions

2021

Federal district court rejects request for an injunction

Apache Stronghold sued federal officials seeking to stop the land exchange. The district court denied preliminary relief, and the case proceeded through appeals.


2022

An initial appellate ruling is vacated for full-court review

A three-judge Ninth Circuit panel initially ruled against Apache Stronghold. The court later agreed to rehear the case en banc, vacating that earlier opinion.


2024

The Ninth Circuit rules against Apache Stronghold

On March 1, the full Ninth Circuit issued a fractured decision rejecting the coalition's request for an injunction. The amended opinion and order were filed May 14.

Different groups of judges agreed on the result but differed in their reasoning. A key majority concluded that the government's disposition of its own land generally does not impose a substantial burden on religious exercise under the governing framework derived from Lyng v. Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association.


May 2025

The Supreme Court declines to hear the appeal

On May 27, the Supreme Court denied Apache Stronghold's petition for certiorari. Justices Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas dissented from that denial.

Gorsuch argued that the case deserved review because of the significance of the sacred site and the legal questions raised by the Ninth Circuit's decision. Justice Samuel Alito did not participate in the decision.


Oct. 2025

The Supreme Court denies rehearing

Apache Stronghold requested reconsideration of the Supreme Court's refusal to hear the case. On October 6, 2025, rehearing was denied. Gorsuch again indicated that he would have granted the request.


2026

The transfer proceeds, and separate legal challenges continue

The Forest Service signed its environmental record of decision on March 16, 2026. In March, the federal government transferred the land to Resolution Copper after an appeals court lifted an injunction. In April, Apache Stronghold filed an updated lawsuit seeking to undo the transfer.


On September 29, the Ninth Circuit denied rehearing in a separate case challenging the land exchange and environmental review. The underlying environmental litigation continued.


What happened in 2026, and why the story is not over

This is the most important update if you're reporting on the case now.

The transfer of Oak Flat to Resolution Copper was completed in March 2026. That does not mean every legal challenge has been resolved.


Apache Stronghold filed an amended complaint in federal district court on April 22, 2026, seeking to reverse the transfer. The coalition raised additional arguments involving federal environmental and historic-preservation laws, as well as the 1852 treaty. Its attorneys argue that courts can unwind the transfer if they determine that it was unlawful. Those are the coalition's legal arguments, not a ruling that the transfer has already been found unlawful.


A separate challenge brought by the San Carlos Apache Tribe and conservation groups focused on the Forest Service's environmental review. On April 8, 2026, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction. On September 29, the court declined to reconsider that ruling en banc. The litigation over the underlying environmental claims was still continuing as of that decision.


The distinction between these proceedings matters: the Supreme Court's denial of Apache Stronghold's original petition did not automatically decide every later claim under environmental or historic-preservation laws.


Why this case matters beyond Oak Flat

The dispute has implications for religious liberty, Indigenous sovereignty, environmental protection, and the relationship between federal land management and minority-faith rights.

  • Indigenous religious freedom: The case asks whether religious protections can meaningfully protect a practice when the land necessary for that practice is owned or controlled by the federal government.

  • The limits of RFRA: The Ninth Circuit's reasoning may influence how courts interpret “substantial burden” when government decisions permanently prevent access to sacred land.

  • Federal land and congressional authority: Congress authorized the exchange in 2014, leaving courts to consider the legal challenges within the framework of that statute and other applicable laws.

  • Environmental consequences: Opponents also raise concerns about groundwater, ecological damage, and the destruction of cultural and archaeological resources.


The case also drew support from religious and Indigenous organizations outside the Apache community. Numerous organizations filed friend-of-the-court briefs during the Supreme Court proceedings, reflecting broader concern about how the ruling could affect religious exercise and the protection of sacred sites.



The Courts, the Constitution, & Minority Faiths

What happened in Atlantic Beach?

On October 21, 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice announced a settlement with the Village of Atlantic Beach, New York, over zoning rules that treated religious places of assembly less favorably than comparable secular gathering places. The federal investigation concluded that the village's zoning code violated RLUIPA's equal-terms provision. The village denied that conclusion but agreed to change its zoning rules and take other compliance measures to avoid the expense and risks of litigation.


The case grew out of a dispute involving Chabad of the Beaches, an Orthodox Jewish congregation that wanted to convert a vacant former bank building into a center for Jewish worship, education, and community programming.


The federal government found that the village required religious or educational places of assembly to obtain a special exception permit from its Board of Appeals, while comparable nonreligious gathering places did not face that same requirement. That difference was central to the federal investigation.


Federal Zoning Cases Highlight Religious Land-Use Protections in 2026

Recent federal actions in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York examine whether religious gatherings face stricter zoning requirements than comparable secular assemblies.


Religious organizations seeking property for worship, ceremonies, and community gatherings have received renewed attention from federal civil-rights officials in 2026. Several cases involving the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) have challenged local zoning rules that require religious assemblies to obtain special permits while allowing comparable nonreligious gatherings to operate without them.


Although the cases involve Jewish and Muslim communities, the legal protections at issue may also be relevant to Pagan organizations seeking permanent spaces for ceremonies, worship, and religious education.


Pennsylvania Borough Agrees to Change Zoning Rules

In February, the U.S. Department of Justice filed a lawsuit against the Borough of Kingston, Pennsylvania, alleging that its zoning ordinance treated religious land uses less favorably than comparable secular assemblies.


The ordinance required places of worship to obtain discretionary special-use permits and restricted them to properties of at least one acre. Comparable nonreligious assemblies, including theaters, bowling alleys, recreational facilities, and libraries, were allowed as of right without the same acreage restriction.


The DOJ said these requirements significantly limited the properties available for religious use, affecting the local Orthodox Jewish Chabad community's ability to establish spaces for prayer, religious study, religious schools, and ritual baths.


A federal court entered a consent order on February 6, requiring Kingston to revise its zoning ordinance, remove the acreage requirements for places of worship and religious schools, and provide comparable treatment regarding issues such as parking and landscaping. The borough was also required to train officials on RLUIPA and establish a process for handling complaints.



Federal Government Supports Mosque in New Jersey Zoning Dispute

In July, the DOJ filed a statement of interest in litigation involving Masjid Sadar, a Muslim congregation seeking to build a mosque in Sayreville, New Jersey.


The congregation's lawsuit alleges that the borough's zoning code requires houses of worship to obtain discretionary conditional-use permits while allowing secular assemblies as of right. The plaintiffs also challenge stricter dimensional requirements imposed on religious uses.

In its court filing, the federal government argued that the zoning code appeared to violate RLUIPA's equal-terms provision because it treated religious assemblies less favorably than comparable nonreligious gatherings without adequate regulatory justification.

The filing represents the federal government's legal position in ongoing litigation, not a final judicial determination that Sayreville violated the law.


What this means for Pagan groups

This is where the story becomes particularly relevant to a minority-faith newsroom.

The DOJ's legal guidance is not restricted to Christianity, Judaism, Islam, or other large, established religions. RLUIPA's language protects religious assemblies and institutions without limiting that protection to particular faith traditions. Its application to Pagan groups depends on the specific circumstances.


A Pagan grove or outdoor sanctuary

A Pagan organization seeks to use or develop a property for regular ceremonies. If a municipality imposes a special permit requirement on the religious assembly while allowing comparable secular gatherings as of right, the equal-terms provision may be relevant.


A home-based circle or coven

A group regularly gathers in a member's home for religious practice, and zoning officials attempt to prohibit the gatherings or impose restrictions. RLUIPA may be relevant if a zoning or land-use regulation restricts the property's religious use and the statutory requirements are met.


A rented meeting space

A Pagan congregation wants to rent a commercial property for services, but the municipality denies the proposed use because it is religious while permitting comparable assembly uses.


A permanent Pagan church or temple

A congregation seeks to establish a dedicated worship space but faces discretionary approvals, repeated denials, or restrictions that do not apply to similar secular institutions.


These are potential applications of existing law, not findings that every example constitutes a violation. The precise legal position depends on ownership or other property interests, the zoning regulation involved, the religious use proposed, the relevant statutory requirements, and the evidence of unequal treatment.


One especially important detail: RLUIPA defines religious exercise broadly, but its land-use provisions concern zoning and landmarking regulations affecting land in which the claimant has a qualifying property interest. It is not a general exemption from every local rule governing gatherings, noise, fire safety, building occupancy, or public land.


Did regional civil-rights lawyers issue new guidance to Pagan groups?

I could verify the DOJ's settlement and its longstanding RLUIPA guidance, but I could not independently verify a new, coordinated guidance campaign by Northeast civil-rights lawyers specifically advising Pagan organizations after October 21.


Where groups can find help

U.S. Department of Justice: Place to Worship Initiative

Official explanations of RLUIPA, enforcement actions, and reporting options.


Harvard Law School Religious Freedom Clinic

The clinic represented Chabad in its earlier dispute with Atlantic Beach, alongside First Liberty Institute and Sidley Austin. Its case materials provide useful historical context, although the availability of representation in other cases is not guaranteed.


First Liberty Institute

The organization participated in Chabad's earlier litigation and maintains case documents and updates about the dispute.



Christian Nationalism, Political Power, & Public Life


“Holy Wars” Conference in Franklin Draws Protests Over Speakers’ Views

A Christian conference at The Factory at Franklin prompted a public debate over religious expression, civil rights, and the responsibilities of venues hosting controversial events.


A three-day Christian conference titled Holy Wars took place October 1–3, 2026, at The Factory at Franklin in Franklin, Tennessee. Organized by the Fight Laugh Feast Network, the event advertised a program exploring “Just War, the Crusades, and the Christian Life.”


The gathering drew public criticism before it began, with a petition opposing the venue’s decision to host the conference attracting thousands of signatures. Critics pointed to statements and positions associated with featured speakers concerning women’s political rights, slavery, and LGBTQ+ people.

Local reporting by WSMV and WKRN documented the controversy surrounding the event and the venue’s response to public concerns.


A conference draws public opposition

The conference was promoted as a Christian gathering focused on theology, warfare, history, and Christian life. Among its featured speakers was Pastor Doug Wilson of Moscow, Idaho, whose past statements on slavery and women’s suffrage drew criticism from opponents of the event.


Catie Fein organized a petition urging The Factory at Franklin to reconsider hosting the conference. Critics argued that providing the venue gave a platform to speakers whose views they considered harmful to women and LGBTQ+ people.


The controversy raised questions about the distinction between hosting an event and endorsing its message, as well as the responsibilities of public-facing venues when the beliefs associated with a booking become a source of community concern.


The venue responds

In a statement reported by WSMV, The Factory at Franklin said it took community concerns seriously but did not endorse or promote the views of the conference or its speakers.


The venue explained that the booking had been made under a contract before its leadership fully understood the event’s subject matter. It also said it was coordinating with organizers and Franklin police to provide additional security during the gathering.


The Factory subsequently said it would review its booking procedures and work with its tenants to improve transparency around future events.


The controversy also affected Saffire, a restaurant located at The Factory. According to WSMV, the restaurant had accepted bookings for private luncheons without initially knowing their connection to the conference. After learning more about the event, its owners expressed concern that the restaurant could appear to endorse the gathering. The conference later canceled those luncheon arrangements.

The episode highlighted a practical challenge for venues and businesses: determining how to respond when a customer’s identity or purpose becomes clear only after a contract has been signed.


Organizers defend the conference

Fight Laugh Feast Network CEO Gabriel Rench responded to the criticism in a statement published by WSMV. He characterized the dispute as a conflict between competing worldviews and described the United States as a Christian nation. He also criticized political opponents and defended the conference’s approach to the issues under debate.


The statement illustrates the broader disagreement surrounding the event. Critics viewed the speakers’ documented positions as a civil-rights concern, while the organizers framed the backlash as opposition to their religious and political convictions.


Those perspectives are not identical questions. The right to express religious beliefs does not automatically settle whether particular political proposals would restrict other people’s rights, just as criticism of a religious organization does not, by itself, establish unlawful discrimination.


Why the controversy matters to minority-faith communities

For Pagan and other minority-faith communities, the event raises questions about the relationship between religious identity, political power, and equal treatment under the law.



The clearest Texas lead: Ted Cruz's “transgender witch” remark

During an October interview about the 2026 midterm elections, the Texas senator used the phrase “left-wing transgender witch” to describe voters he expected to oppose Donald Trump. The full remarks raise questions about how political identity, gender identity, and religious imagery are used in campaign rhetoric.


On October 17, 2026, U.S. Senator Ted Cruz of Texas appeared on Fox News alongside Alaska Senator Dan Sullivan to discuss the upcoming midterm elections and the closely contested Senate races that could determine control of the chamber.


During the interview, Cruz discussed voter turnout, Republican electoral prospects, and the possibility of Democrats gaining seats. In explaining why voters aligned with the party out of power might be especially motivated to participate, he used the phrase “left-wing transgender witch” to describe people he expected to oppose President Donald Trump.


The remark attracted attention because it combined a political label, a reference to transgender identity, and a term associated with religious and spiritual traditions, including contemporary Witchcraft and some Pagan paths.


The complete passage provides important context for understanding how Cruz framed the election and the voters he believed would participate.


What Cruz said

The following is the full passage provided from Cruz’s October 17 interview, beginning with his discussion of possible Senate outcomes and continuing through his appeal for Republican turnout:

Now, we could have a great election night. You know, what I am hoping is that we hold all of our Senate seats and we win, gain Senate seats in Michigan, and in New Hampshire, and Minnesota, and Georgia. That’s possible. That would be a great night. We would come out with 57 Republicans. That would be a home run night.But it’s also possible that we come into the night and we lose five to eight seats, and the Democrats end up with 55 Democrats — that would be a disaster. And it’s right on the edge, and it all comes down to turnout. You asked why this is happening — this happens a lot in midterms, where the party out of power, they’re usually ticked off. And right now, if you’re a left-wing transgender witch, you hate Donald Trump.And you’re gonna show up, you’re energized. and the question is, does everybody else show up? Do conservatives show up? Do Libertarians show up? Just commonsense Americans who are not lunatics who don’t think Communism and Islamism are a good idea. If regular, ordinary Americans show up to vote, Dan Sullivan’s gonna be reelected here in Alaska, and we’re gonna win Senate seats and House seats all over the country.

The language and its context

Cruz’s statement was part of an argument about electoral participation. He suggested that voters dissatisfied with the party in power would be particularly motivated to vote, then contrasted those voters with conservatives, Libertarians, and what he called “regular, ordinary Americans.”


The phrase “left-wing transgender witch” is notable because it groups three different characteristics into one description. “Left-wing” identifies a political orientation. “Transgender” refers to gender identity. “Witch” can be used as an insult or caricature, but it is also a term embraced by people who practice Witchcraft and by some members of Pagan religious communities.


Cruz did not explain what he meant by “witch,” identify any particular religious tradition, or state that he was referring to Wiccans or Pagans specifically. The available remarks also do not establish that he was describing actual transgender people who practice Witchcraft. It would therefore be inaccurate to present the comment as an explicit statement about Pagan voters as a group.


At the same time, the wording invites questions about the role religious imagery plays in political communication. When a term associated with a minority spiritual tradition appears in a description of an opposing political group, readers may reasonably consider whether the language reinforces familiar stereotypes, regardless of whether that was the speaker’s intent.


The contrast with “regular, ordinary Americans” is another part of the passage worth examining. Cruz did not explicitly say that all transgender people, Witches, or left-wing voters were outside the American public. However, placing the phrase “left-wing transgender witch” immediately before his description of “regular, ordinary Americans” creates a contrast that readers may interpret in different ways.


Why the wording may matter to Pagan communities

For Pagans, Witches, and other minority-faith practitioners, the issue is not simply whether a politician agrees with their beliefs. Religious freedom protects the ability to hold, practice, and express religious beliefs, including beliefs that are unfamiliar or unpopular with the majority.


The use of “witch” as a political caricature raises a broader question: how do references to minority religious identities function when they are used to characterize political opponents?

There are several considerations worth separating.


Religious identity and political identity are not interchangeable. Paganism and Witchcraft encompass diverse traditions, practices, and personal beliefs. Neither term automatically identifies someone's political affiliation, views on Donald Trump, or voting behavior.


A rhetorical reference is not proof of discriminatory policy. Cruz’s remark does not, on its own, establish that he supports restricting Pagan religious practice or denying religious protections to Witches. Any claim about his policy positions would require examination of his legislative record, public statements, and actions concerning religious liberty.


Language can carry different meanings for different audiences. A speaker may intend a phrase as political mockery, while people whose identities are invoked may hear it as dismissive or stigmatizing. Reporting can document those differences without assuming a single interpretation for everyone.

These distinctions matter when evaluating political rhetoric involving minority communities. They allow the public to consider the words and their potential implications without treating an inference about intent as an established fact.


A question of representation

The broader significance of the remark depends partly on how political language shapes the public's understanding of the people it describes.


Witches and Pagans are not a uniform political constituency. They include people with different political views, religious practices, gender identities, and interpretations of their spiritual traditions. Some may view Cruz’s wording as an irrelevant political jab; others may see the use of “witch” as part of a longer history of using minority religious identities to portray people as threatening, irrational, or outside the mainstream.


The full passage also makes clear that Cruz was urging voters to participate in an election. Its immediate subject was political mobilization, not religious policy. That context should remain central to any assessment of the remarks.


Nevertheless, the language provides an opportunity to consider how public figures invoke religious and personal identities while drawing distinctions between political groups. Such questions are particularly relevant to minority-faith communities, whose members may already encounter misconceptions about their beliefs and practices.


What the remarks establish, and what remains open to interpretation

The documented facts are straightforward: on October 17, Cruz used the phrase “left-wing transgender witch” during a Fox News discussion of midterm election turnout. He followed it by referring to “commonsense Americans who are not lunatics” and “regular, ordinary Americans” in his appeal for voters to support Republican candidates.


What the statement means beyond that context is open to interpretation. The available remarks do not demonstrate that Cruz was targeting Pagan religious practice specifically, nor do they establish a policy proposal affecting Witches or Pagans.


Readers can still consider the language, its placement in the broader passage, and the distinctions it draws between groups of voters. Whether they interpret it as political shorthand, ridicule, or language that risks reinforcing stereotypes is a question that can be examined through the words themselves.

For a minority-faith community, the underlying question is worth asking: when religious identity becomes part of political rhetoric, how should the public distinguish ordinary political disagreement from language that may marginalize the people whose identities are being invoked?

Editorial Note: The quote is the only thing thats pulled from a verified souce, we took the verbiage and analized and dissected it to give yall the opportunity to draw your own conclusions about the greater implications to our community.


A second lead: Texas campaigns and religious identity

Mayes Middleton’s support for a more prominent role for Christianity in government has drawn scrutiny from religious-freedom advocates as he campaigns to become Texas’ top legal officer.

In an October 9 report, The Texas Tribune examined Republican attorney general candidate Mayes Middleton’s record on religion and government, including his support for Ten Commandments displays in public school classrooms and his opposition to separation of church and state as a guiding principle.


Middleton, a state senator from Galveston, has described the separation of church and state as a “false doctrine.” In comments to Katy Christian Magazine in 2025, he stated, “There is no such thing as ‘separation of church and state’ in our Constitution, and our schools are not God-free zones.”


Middleton helped advance a Texas law requiring public school classrooms to display the Ten Commandments. After a federal judge blocked enforcement of the law in 11 school districts, Middleton donated Ten Commandments posters to his home school district and urged officials to display them. When the school board declined amid pending litigation, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued, and a judge ordered the district to hang the displays.


The Tribune also reported that Middleton supported legislation permitting prayer time during the school day and a law allowing religious chaplains to serve in public schools. At a conservative Christian event, Middleton said his priority as attorney general would be to remind Texans that “our rights come from God, not government.”


These positions have drawn support from conservative Christian advocates who see them as efforts to protect religious expression. They have also raised concerns among religious-freedom organizations and non-Christian Texans about whether government institutions would give Christianity preferential treatment.


Douglas Laycock, a religious law scholar at the University of Texas, told the Tribune that government actively supporting one religion can discriminate against other religions. The report also documented Middleton’s criticism of what he called the “Islamification of Texas,” placing his views on church-state relations within a broader discussion of how religious liberty is applied to different faith communities.

The attorney general’s office has significant influence over Texas law and policy. Beyond defending the state in court, the office can initiate lawsuits, file legal briefs, conduct investigations, and issue legal opinions that influence how state and local officials interpret the law. The Tribune noted that advocates on different sides of church-state disputes expect Middleton to take an active approach to these issues if elected.


For Pagan, Wiccan, polytheist, and other minority-faith communities, the central question is how government policies involving religion would affect people whose beliefs differ from those of the Christian majority. A policy that gives one tradition a privileged position in public institutions can raise questions about equal treatment, even when its supporters describe it as an expression of religious heritage.


Middleton’s reported positions are relevant to that discussion, but they should not be mistaken for evidence that he has specifically targeted Pagan religions or Witchcraft. The documented record concerns his approach to Christianity in government, church-state separation, public education, and his statements about Islam.


As the Texas attorney general race continues, Middleton’s public statements and legislative record offer a basis for examining how his interpretation of religious liberty could shape the state’s legal approach to religion and government.


Texas Candidate’s Comments on Religious Inclusion Resurface

Jon Rosenthal’s 2018 remarks on legislative prayer have renewed discussion about how minority faiths are represented in public life.


A resurfaced 2018 interview featuring Jon Rosenthal, the Democratic nominee for the Texas Railroad Commission, has renewed discussion about religious inclusion in government, particularly whether people from minority-faith traditions should have the same opportunity to participate in legislative prayer as members of more widely practiced religions.


In an interview with The Trans Advocate while campaigning for the Texas House of Representatives, Rosenthal discussed his views on prayer before legislative proceedings. He said he did not oppose the practice, provided that lawmakers were willing to include different religious traditions.

“I don’t care if someone wants to have a prayer in front of the service,” Rosenthal said. “But I think if you want to do that, you pretty much have to include everybody, right?”

During the conversation, Rosenthal suggested that Wiccans should be allowed to participate alongside other religious groups. When an interviewer raised the Satanic Temple as another example, Rosenthal agreed that different traditions should be included if lawmakers chose to permit legislative prayer.


“Then as long as you’re fine with everyone taking their turn at this, then I’m down for that,” he said.

The comments resurfaced in an October 8, 2026, article published by Texas Scorecard, which highlighted Rosenthal’s willingness to include Wiccans and the Satanic Temple in legislative prayer. The outlet reported that Rosenthal’s campaign had not responded to its request for comment before publication.


A Broader Conversation About Religious Liberty

Legislative prayer has long been the subject of debate over religious freedom, government involvement in religious expression, and equal treatment of different faith traditions.


The U.S. Supreme Court has addressed legislative prayer in cases including Marsh v. Chambers (1983) and Town of Greece v. Galloway (2014). These decisions upheld particular legislative and municipal prayer practices, while leaving important questions about the circumstances and implementation of such practices.


For minority-faith communities, the issue raises a practical question: if a government body chooses to open its proceedings with prayer, how should it approach invitations to representatives of different religious traditions?


Rosenthal’s remarks addressed that question through the principle of inclusion. His comments did not establish that Wiccans or members of the Satanic Temple subsequently led prayers before the Texas Legislature, nor did the interview itself change legislative policy.


Rosenthal later served four terms in the Texas House, representing District 135. According to The Texas Tribune, he has also spoken publicly about religious diversity and church-state separation, including his opposition to legislation requiring the Ten Commandments to be displayed in public school classrooms.

As the remarks circulate again, they offer an opportunity to examine how religious inclusion is discussed in public institutions and what equal participation means for communities whose beliefs are less familiar to the wider public.


For minority-faith communities across Texas and beyond, the conversation extends beyond one candidate’s comments: it concerns whether religious diversity is treated as a principle that applies to everyone.

Editorial Note: PUP has reached out for comment but has not recieved a response yet


National Council of Churches Reaffirms Religious Freedom for People of All Faiths

An October gathering in Philadelphia renewed a prominent Christian coalition’s call for religious liberty, freedom of conscience, and equal treatment across faith traditions.


The National Council of the Churches of Christ in the USA (NCC), an ecumenical body representing 37 Christian communions, adopted a statement on religious freedom during its October 12–16, 2026, Christian Unity Gathering in Philadelphia. The statement, Recommitment to Religious Freedom, affirms that religious liberty must extend to all people, regardless of their faith, and rejects efforts to privilege one religion over others.


The council’s position was also reflected in remarks by Archbishop Elpidophoros of America, chair of the NCC Governing Board, during the gathering. Addressing the relationship between religion and government, he said the First Amendment protects both the freedom to practice a religion and the freedom from government-imposed religion.


Elpidophoros emphasized that the constitutional guarantee of free exercise applies across religious traditions and that no religious group should impose its beliefs on society. He distinguished between dialogue and persuasion, which he described as legitimate parts of religious life, and compulsion by the state.


For religious minorities, including Pagans, Witches, polytheists, and others whose beliefs fall outside dominant religious traditions, these principles are particularly relevant. The NCC’s statement does not create new legal protections, but it represents a public affirmation from a major Christian coalition that religious liberty should not be limited to its own members.


The distinction between religious expression and government endorsement remains central to debates over religious freedom in the United States. Individuals and religious organizations may express their beliefs and advocate for their views, while government institutions remain bound by constitutional requirements governing religion and the state.


The NCC’s statement also comes amid ongoing national debate over Christian nationalism and the role of Christianity in American public life. During the gathering, Elpidophoros directly challenged the idea that the United States is intended to be a Christian nation, arguing that the country’s founding principles do not permit the government to impose a particular religious identity.


The statement is not a court ruling, and it does not establish that every member denomination holds identical views on every question involving church-state relations. Its significance lies in the position the council has publicly articulated: religious freedom must protect people across faith traditions rather than privilege one religious community.


For Pagan and other minority-faith communities, the broader question is how these principles translate into government policy, court decisions, and everyday institutional practice. Public affirmations of religious liberty are one part of that conversation; ensuring equal treatment in practice remains an ongoing concern.




Harassment, Intolerance, & Safety in Pagan Communities

Theme: Direct experiences of discrimination and responses from Pagan organizations

Subtitle: From national statements to disruptions at community gatherings, Pagans are responding to hostility while working to protect the spaces where they gather, worship, and belong.



 Pagan Federation Calls for Religious Respect Amid Rising Anti-Pagan Hostility

The UK organization reaffirms its commitment to religious equality, interfaith cooperation, and the right of Pagans to practice their faith without harassment.


The Pagan Federation issued a public statement on October 10, 2026, titled Standing Together Against Religious Intolerance, addressing what the organization describes as growing disrespect, misinformation, and targeted online attacks against Pagan communities.


In the statement, published on its official website, the Federation emphasized its commitment to religious equality and the right of people from all faith traditions to practice their beliefs peacefully. It also highlighted its work representing Pagan interests in government, healthcare, prisons, chaplaincies, and interfaith settings.


The Federation said it works to address discrimination, misinformation, and barriers that prevent Pagans from practicing their faith. It also stressed the importance of spiritual safeguarding and mutual understanding across religious communities.


The Pagan Federation's statement challenges the use of personal spiritual experiences to belittle or diminish other religious traditions. The organization stated that it does not consider one spiritual path inherently superior to another and argued that misinformation and hostility undermine mutual understanding.


The Federation also directed community members toward its available support resources, including advocacy assistance, safeguarding guidance, and pastoral care. These services are intended to help individuals facing concerns related to their spiritual practices, community experiences, or other areas of their lives.


The statement does not call for an end to religious disagreement. Instead, it draws a distinction between expressing one's own beliefs and using those beliefs to undermine the legitimacy or dignity of others.


For Pagan communities, that distinction has practical implications. Public descriptions of unfamiliar spiritual traditions can shape how those traditions are understood, particularly when claims circulate online or enter institutional settings such as healthcare, prisons, and chaplaincies.


Religious freedom includes the ability to follow minority traditions, even when their beliefs differ substantially from those of the religious majority. Protecting that freedom requires room for disagreement while respecting the rights and dignity of people from different faith backgrounds.


Through its October statement, the Pagan Federation reaffirmed its commitment to advocating for Pagan communities and promoting peaceful religious practice. Its message centers on a straightforward principle: religious differences need not disappear for people of different faiths to coexist with respect.




Advocacy, Representation, & Religious Freedom


Circle Sanctuary Joins National Interfaith Tour to Protect Voting Rights

Pagan ministers Rev. Selena Fox and Rev. Becky Malke joined a multifaith effort connecting religious diversity with civic participation and election protection.


Two ministers from Circle Sanctuary, a Wisconsin-based Pagan religious organization, joined the national The Vote Is Sacred bus tour in October, bringing Pagan representation to a broader interfaith effort focused on voting rights and democratic participation.


Rev. Selena Fox and Rev. Becky Malke participated in the tour's Madison-area event on October 9, 2026, according to The Wild Hunt. They joined representatives of other religious traditions in supporting civic engagement and affirming the importance of religious diversity.


Organized by Interfaith Alliance, The Vote Is Sacred is a nonpartisan initiative ahead of the November 2026 midterm elections. The campaign focuses on four areas: voter education, voter participation, election protection, and resources for faith communities and civic organizations.


The tour brings together religious leaders and local organizations for voter-engagement activities, election-protection training, and community events. Its stated purpose is to help faith communities encourage participation in elections while preparing for potential disruptions to the democratic process.


For Circle Sanctuary, participation provides a public example of Pagan ministers engaging alongside leaders from other faith traditions in a shared civic initiative. The involvement also illustrates how minority religious communities can contribute to conversations about voting rights and democratic institutions without abandoning their own spiritual identities.


The initiative is explicitly nonpartisan. Its focus is voter participation and election protection rather than support for a particular candidate or political party.


The tour's broader message is that civic participation can be a shared concern across religious differences. By bringing Pagan leaders into a national interfaith setting, the event also highlights the presence of minority faith communities in public life.


As the November 3 election approaches, The Vote Is Sacred is continuing its multistate schedule, connecting local faith communities with voter education and election-protection resources.




Pagan Community, Education, & Mutual Aid

Theme: Education, community events, charity, and the infrastructure that sustains Pagan life

Subtitle: Beyond the headlines, Pagan organizations continue to build community through education, local gatherings, charitable initiatives, and practical support.

17. Nashville Pagan Pride Prepares for Yuletide

Focus: Nashville, Tennessee


Nashville Pagan Pride has announced a seasonal community gathering as the organization looks ahead to its 2027 festival.


The Yuletide Snacks and Crafts Gathering is scheduled for December 5, 2026, at Many Paths Spiritual Center, according to Nashville Pagan Pride’s announcement.


The gathering follows the organization’s free Pagan Pride festival. Nashville Pagan Pride said the additional event will help offset the production costs associated with hosting the festival while providing another opportunity for community members to connect.


The organization has also opened early-bird applications for vendor spaces at its 2027 festival. Applications are available through October 31, 2026.


The announcements offer a look at how local Pagan organizations balance accessible, free community events with the fundraising and planning needed to keep those events running.




Astrological Outlook: October 25–November 1, 2026

Relationships, reflection, and finding your footing

The coming week brings a powerful mix of astrological energy, with a Taurus Full Moon, Venus retrograde moving into Libra, and Mercury retrograde in Scorpio encouraging reflection, reassessment, and more intentional communication.


The week begins with a focus on relationships and balance. Venus retrograde returns to Libra on October 25, bringing attention to fairness, boundaries, and reciprocity. This is a good time to reflect on whether relationships feel mutually supportive and whether the desire to keep the peace is overshadowing your own needs.


On October 26, the Full Moon in Taurus shifts attention toward stability, finances, self-worth, and the things that help us feel grounded. Its themes invite us to consider what we truly value and whether our current priorities reflect those values.


Communication may require extra care throughout the week. With Mercury retrograde in Scorpio and tense planetary aspects involving Mars, misunderstandings or emotionally charged conversations may call for patience. Taking time to verify information, reconsider assumptions, and think before responding can help prevent unnecessary conflict.


As the week closes, the astrological themes turn toward reassessment and adjustment. Rather than pushing for immediate answers, consider what needs to change and where a more sustainable approach may serve you better.


As Samhain approaches, this week's astrology offers a fitting invitation: honor what has passed, examine what remains, and make room for what you want to carry forward. Ground your reflections in practical action, and remember that not every question needs an immediate answer.



PUP- dates Incoming:


Pagan Unity Press has a subreddit!


We’re excited to open up another space for our community to connect, share perspectives, ask questions, and have conversations that don’t always fit into a news article or social media post.


We hope this subreddit becomes a place for more freeform discussions, thoughtful conversations, and community connection. Whether you want to discuss current events, share your experiences, ask questions, or explore topics affecting Pagan and minority faith communities, we want to make room for those voices.


Pagan Unity Press is about more than reporting the news. It’s about building community, making information accessible, and creating space for people to learn from one another.

Where All Paths Have a Voice.


Come join the conversation, and help us grow this new corner of our community!


Another way to stay connected with Pagan Unity Press!

We’ve officially opened submissions for our email mailing list!


If you’d like to have PUP’s articles delivered straight to your inbox, you can now sign up to stay up to date on the latest news, community stories, and developments affecting Pagan and minority faith communities.


Social media feeds can be unpredictable, and we want to make it easier for you to stay informed without having to worry about whether an article shows up in your feed.

Our goal has always been to make news easier for everyone, and this is one more step toward making that happen.


Thank you for continuing to grow with us and supporting our mission to give overlooked voices a place to be heard.


Sign up here



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page